Nandigram is nothing in comparison with Kronstad - Lenin to Budhya a right sequel of Communism

Feel pity for Karl Marx

Hindol Bhattacharjee
24 December

I have read some of the books regarding the state terrorism practiced by Communists. I am confused and after thinking a lot, to me Marxism has been misused by the power hunger of dictators about whom still i am respectful. But now i am a bit confused.

You know well that after the revolution in Russia, Lenin tried to make a parliamentary election and it was termed as Constituent assembly. But after getting only 150 seats out of 700, he broke the parliament and declared the dictatorship. Some people tried to assassinate him but in stead of that he formed the Red army whose activity was only to kill and demolish all the against parties of Lenin and Communist party. Between 1918 and 1921, in the civil war, the red army killed a lot. Besides there was scarcity of food and in this way when there was people's uprising against the mundane communism, 7.5 Million people were killed. Lenin termed this as " war Communism'. Lenin, to fight against all the opponent, created Cheka whose activity was centralized in political murders of those opponents and torture over the farmers. During that period, all the trade unions and strikes were banned. Lenin has declared that to gain communism, Russa should be civilized. But what was the form of that Civilization? Due to war communism, and people's uprising, in Kronstad, thousands of people were killed. The sailors who directly participated in the revolution( 1905, October, February, 1917) had become opponent of Lenin. They created another coupd'eta against lenin and the sustaining communist terrorism. At the same time the people's uprising movements, especially by farmers and workers were taking place.

The sailors of Kronstad made a resolution after 26 February of 1921 and their demands were most democratic. They needed election for a new Soviet by hidden ballot, they needed equal distribution of ration, and the freedom of speech along with the freedom of participating in Trade Union and farmers Union. But Lenin termed it as a conspiracy done by the white force against the red army. ( Like our Binoy Kongar declared the mass movement was a conspiracy by the Maoists at nandigram). Kujmin declared that war would be the solution ( like our Biman Bose gave public statements against the farmers who are fighting against the land acquisition for SEZ), and Trotsky sent 60000 soldiers of red army to kronstad to kill the organised farmers ( like lakhman Seth at nandigram)

It is a truth that in this battle the number of deaths of sailors was 527. Injured was 4127. More than 500 leaders of the uprising mass movement were sent to Siberia.

Kronstad is well known for a victory of Lenin over the mass movement and it is still now a landmark of Communist movement. From this perspective, how can we say Budhyadeb Bhattacharjee, Biman Bose, Binoy Kongar are not communists. They are not marxists as lenin was not a marxist, too.

If we go through the recent economic condition of China after globalization, it is really shivering. During 1995-2002, 15% of the number of labours was decreased. The decrease is from 980 lakh to 830 lakh. They are getting smaller revenue, working more than 12 hours per day and working 7 days per week. Due to the rapid conversion of agricultural land to industrial sector, the farmers of Guangshi area is now gradually worsen. Due to the land acquisition, 26.7 square kilometre land has become desert. It is 29.7% of the total agricultural land. After globalisation, the per apita income of 90% of the population of China is now 1.4% of the total income of the country whereas 10% middle class people are now getting more than 45% income if GNI.

The left front has decided to accept the globalise economy and in the process of manifestation of SEZ. According to history, Budhya, prabhat, prakash karat are obviously communists and nandigram is nothing if it is compared with kronstad. And now they are going to become a part of processing the globalise economy in bengal and helping Indian central government to help multinationals.

Is it Communism? Or, perhaps yes it is!